Are you on Team Overhand? Don't sit on that knowledge, share it with the world!
Perhaps you rock the other side of the fence? Stand up and show your pride! Team Underhand!
If you want to upload your button as your Facebook profile picture make sure that you go to your photo albums first and click "Upload Pictures". Once you have uploaded it to one of your albums you can set it as your profile pic. If you try to go the direct route and make it your default picture without uploading that way it claims that the picture is too small.